Italian bishop provides youngsters harsh information: there isn’t any Santa Claus

All that separated the giddy Sicilian college youngsters from assembly Old St. Nick — arriving on horseback along with his lengthy white beard, crimson gown and bag filled with presents — was a Christmas message from the bishop of Noto.
“Santa Claus,” thundered Bishop Antonio Staglianò, “is an imaginary character.”
Children’s jaws dropped and the vacation wool fell from their eyes as, for a lot of lengthy minutes within the Santissimo Salvatore Basilica, the bishop continued to stay it to Santa, who he mentioned had no real interest in households strapped for money.

“The red colour of his coat was chosen by Coca-Cola for advertising purposes,” the bishop mentioned. Big soda, he added, “uses the image to depict itself as an emblem of healthy values.”
The bishop’s broadside in opposition to Babbo Natale, as Father Christmas is named right here, constituted solely the newest installment in what has develop into a brand new Italian vacation custom. Just about yearly, Roman Catholic clerics insist that for Italians to maintain Christ in Christmas, Santa have to be saved out of it.
In 2019, a priest within the northern city of Magliano Alpi instructed youngsters that there was no man wearing purple who “magically” delivered presents. In 2018, within the Sardinian metropolis of Quartu Sant’Elena, one other priest drew tears by revealing that Santa Claus was in actual fact none aside from their mothers and dads.
The San Nicola Basilica within the southern Italian metropolis of Bari, on July 17, 2018. (Stephanie Gengotti/The New York Times)
This yr’s episode, on Dec 6, the feast day of St. Nicholas, was particularly brazen, mentioned Giuliana Scarnato, one of many lecturers accompanying the youngsters, none older than 9, on a college journey to the church in Noto.
She mentioned the bishop “could have left Santa Claus out of it” however made some extent to say that Father Christmas was “fantastical, that he never existed.” She mentioned that when one of many youngsters protested, telling the bishop that her mother and father had assured her Santa was actual, the cleric responded that the kid ought to inform her mother and father “you tell lies.”
Staglianò mentioned he remembered placing it extra tactfully and insisted he merely defined that the roots for Santa — whom he depicted as a noxious product of the industrial-soft drink-consumerism advanced — lay within the historic personage of St. Nicholas, a charitable fourth century bishop of Myra, in modern-day Turkey, who, custom holds, taken care of the poor.
He had robust emotions on the matter.
“Is Father Christmas everyone’s father, or just some?” he mentioned, poking holes within the case for Santa Claus. “In the lockdown, Father Christmas didn’t visit the families that he used to. Why? It’s definitely not for fear of the coronavirus.”
The bishop recalled warmly the times when Italian youngsters would deal with their want lists to the infant Jesus, “not Santa Claus and the reindeer and let’s go to the movies and go bowling and all this American junk.”
This yr, nationalists opened a brand new entrance in Italy’s struggle over the form of Christmas. Desperate for a difficulty with standard attraction in a interval of political stability, they’ve picked up on the American proper’s declare to be opposing a warfare on Christmas.
For them, the primary goal has been not Santa Claus however the European Union.
In November, a conservative Italian newspaper found that an EU commissioner’s workplace had drafted pointers for inside correspondence, calling for extra inclusive, gender-neutral and fewer holiday-specific language.
“Not everyone celebrates the Christian holidays, and not all Christians celebrate them on the same dates,” learn the doc, which suggested workers to keep away from phrases like “Christmas time can be stressful.” Better, it steered, could be “Holiday times can be stressful.”
The stress got here instantly, with far-right leaders going to city.
Matteo Salvini, a nationalist chief and former deputy prime minister, posted on social media an image of a decapitated statue of the Virgin Mary in a ditch.

Grosseto. Statue del presepe in piazza Duomo decapitate e vigilante ferito. Ditemi se vi par normale… pic.twitter.com/A4ZsrueJF6
— Matteo Salvini (@matteosalvinimi) December 13, 2021
Salvini, who just isn’t particularly non secular however usually portrays himself as a defender of Christianity, wrote on Facebook, “The European Commission invites us not to celebrate Holy Christmas to not offend others, and some moron does these gross things.”
Another right-wing nationalist politician, Giorgia Meloni, instructed the conservative newspaper Libero that the EU steering was “shameful.”
“No one can feel offended by a child who is born in a manger,” she added.
Even Pope Francis — who has steered that nationalist leaders are un-Christian for his or her opposition to migrants — has echoed them relating to cancelling Christmas.
Pope Francis (Reuters)
Asked concerning the EU doc earlier this month, Francis mentioned, “This is an anachronism,” and accused the bloc of following within the footsteps of totalitarians. “In history many, many dictatorships have tried” to undercut the church, he mentioned. “Think of Napoleon. From there, think of the Nazi dictatorship, the communist one.”
But Francis has not rallied to defend Santa from his personal bishop’s remarks, and the Vatican has not returned a request for remark.
Staglianò argued he was totally according to Francis.
“With all due respect,” he mentioned, “Santa Claus only brings gifts to those who have money,” whether or not the youngsters are naughty or good.
The poor households and migrants he visits each Christmas, he mentioned, “have never seen Santa Claus.” So he urged the youngsters within the church to ask Santa Claus for much more presents and, if he confirmed up, clarify to him that they may now give to poor youngsters, “given that you never visit them!”
He mentioned not one of the moms within the church dared contradict him, and a few youngsters, emboldened by his preaching, spoke up with the ability of revelation. “I always knew it, that my dad was Santa Claus,” he mentioned one youngster introduced.
Breaking this Christmas “spell” was progress, the bishop mentioned, recalling that as a small youngster he wrote letters asking Santa for cash and put them beneath his father’s dinner plate. He’d discover an envelope with just a few thousand outdated Italian lire beneath his pillow.
But he knew at age 4 it was his father, he mentioned, and argued that the 7-year-olds within the pews knew the rating full nicely, too. The 62-year-old bishop mentioned he hadn’t shattered any sugar plum illusions.
“If we knew,” he mentioned, referring to his era, “imagine these kids with their smartphones.”
Tradition holds that St. Nicholas was sort to youngsters and gave chilly cash to 3 poor sisters who would have in any other case turned to prostitution. Over the centuries he grew to become a patron saint of, amongst different issues, youngsters, pawnbrokers and Russia. Still in the present day, many Russians journey to the southern Italian metropolis of Bari the place his relics, stolen by sailors centuries in the past, are saved within the San Nicola Basilica.
The custom of St. Nicholas finally unfold north, the place the Dutch referred to as him Sinterklaas, a variant of St. Nicholas. The Dutch settled New Amsterdam, later New York, the place English audio system within the American colonies Anglicised the saint’s identify to Santa Claus.
The reindeer, sleigh, Christmas Eve deliveries and massive stomach had been added within the nineteenth century — as was the purple coat, which was customary Santa garb lengthy earlier than Coca-Cola obtained concerned.
But as soon as Santa began hawking sodas, all of it went downhill, Staglianò instructed the youngsters within the church.
Attempting to include the fallout, a diocese spokesperson, Don Alessandro Paolino, wrote on the diocesan Facebook web page, “on behalf of the bishop, I express my sorrow for this declaration which has created disappointment in the little ones, and want to specify that Monsignor Staglianò’s intentions were quite different.”
He then picked up the place the bishop left off, decrying “Santa Claus aka consumerism, the desire to own, buy, buy and buy again.”

Staglianò mentioned that he was not in opposition to all gift-giving however that it needed to be a thoughtful current, nicely chosen — when not in shops, then “delivered by Amazon” — and given by hand.
Despite the fervor of his anti-Santa salvo, it was finally no match for the sight of Old St. Nick on horseback outdoors the church. The youngsters clamored round him as he dismounted, took a seat on a purple throne and handed out pencils, sweet and different presents, mentioned Scarnato, the instructor.
“Once they were outside the church the speech wore off because they were smitten with St. Nicholas,” she mentioned. “They were happy.”