When a relative overseas repays mortgage, foreign exchange positive factors are usually not taxable

Sometimes, taxpayers can land in a novel scenario. They might make some financial positive factors that aren’t specified underneath revenue tax legal guidelines. In such circumstances, the taxation will depend on the interpretation of the provisions underneath the I-T Act. One prevalent instance of that is how bitcoins generated through the “mining” course of might be taxed. There are completely different views on this as it isn’t lined underneath tax legal guidelines.

In such uncommon and distinctive conditions, the assessee might take the view that the positive factors are usually not taxable as they don’t seem to be lined underneath any I-T rules. The assessing officer, nonetheless, will have a look at it as a income loss for the federal government. Officers normally attempt to tax such positive factors.

Let’s have a look at one other instance. Suppose you give a $100,000 private mortgage to a relative staying overseas with out charging any curiosity. Say, the change charge was ₹70 for a greenback. The lender might want to switch ₹70 lakh from India. The borrower repays the cash after some years. At the time of compensation, the rupee weakens towards the greenback. Say, it’s ₹76 for a greenback. When the borrower transfers $100,000, the lender will obtain ₹76 lakh. Due to the change charge distinction, the lender makes ₹6 lakh further. There is not any provision underneath the I-T Act for such positive factors.

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Mumbai, not too long ago handled the same case. It held that positive factors arising as a result of foreign exchange fluctuation when receiving compensation of a private mortgage is not going to be taxable.

During an evaluation, a tax officer observed that a person had obtained ₹1.12 crore. The taxpayer defined that he had prolonged an interest-free private mortgage to his cousin in Singapore. The remittance was made underneath the Liberalised Remittance Scheme (LRS) of the Reserve Bank of India.

Due to a change within the change charge, the quantity obtained on compensation was greater than the cash superior initially. The taxpayer stated that the mortgage was purely private—it was not within the nature of a enterprise transaction. There was no motive for financial positive factors on this transaction. The assessing officer, nonetheless, opined that the positive factors have been taxable and made additions to the revenue, classifying them as curiosity revenue.

“The Mumbai ITAT held that the cash that the assessee had obtained couldn’t be taxed as revenue until it’s a income receipt, or there are provisions to tax it underneath the legislation,” stated Naveen Wadhwa, a chartered accountant and deputy common supervisor at Taxmann.com, a number one writer on taxation and company legal guidelines.

The ITAT dominated in favour of the taxpayer, saying positive factors as a result of forex fluctuation on this occasion shouldn’t be taxed.

Subscribe to Mint Newsletters * Enter a legitimate e-mail * Thank you for subscribing to our publication.

Never miss a narrative! Stay related and knowledgeable with Mint.
Download
our App Now!!