Global shares: Small buyers might face brunt of 20% TCS

Gurugram-based Prasad has been planning to speculate ₹10 lakh in US tech shares however now he’s not sure. “I don’t pay advance tax so I can’t regulate TCS in opposition to it. I can’t declare this as an funding both to my employer,” he said. TCS can be claimed at the time of filing the income tax return.

View Full Image

Graphic: Mint

Apart from hiking the TCS rate, the government also proposed to remove the ₹7 lakh minimum threshold beyond which TCS would apply.

“At least the threshold should have been retained. I’m not willing to idle away a huge chunk of my investible surplus for almost a year,” stated Prasad. To be certain, the federal government pays 6% curiosity every year from the top of the monetary yr on the TCS quantity.

Currently, remittances over ₹7 lakh entice 5% TCS. Other key remittances impacted by these proposals embrace tour packages, items, international transactions by way of debit and journey playing cards and buy of immovable properties.

Data from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) reveals that about $19.6 billion was remitted outdoors India in 2021-22. Outward remittances underneath the LRS have been growing steadily over the previous few years and this development was robust in 2022-23 as properly. In November, the foreign exchange outflow underneath LRS was about $2 billion, up from $1.54 billion in November 2021.

Experts stated the federal government may very well be attempting to money in on this regular progress in outward remittances underneath the LRS.

“It may very well be a step in direction of cash-flow administration. TCS doesn’t give cash to the federal government, so this hike gained’t create income. Rather, it is going to create a beneficiant money circulate. Also, it is going to discourage illegitimate transactions being executed by way of the LRS channel,” said Sitashwa Srivastava, co-founder and co-CEO, Stockal.

Under LRS, each Indian resident can remit up to $250,000 (about ₹2 crore) overseas in a financial year.

Of the $19.6 billion outward remittance pie in 2021, the largest portion of about $6.9 billion went towards travel. The share of investment in equity/debt stood at a rather modest $746 million. “Investments are a very small component of the total outward remittances and I feel the government’s focus was more on travel and other areas that have huge remittance volumes,” stated Srivastava.

But, the TCS hike will considerably push the upfront prices for these trying to spend money on abroad securities. Cost of direct offshore investing is already fairly excessive as a result of foreign exchange unfold and charges charged by banks (see graphics).

One can argue that the TCS credit score may be claimed later and doesn’t qualify as a price per se. Delhi-based Sanjeev Kohli is one such investor. “Since the cash will come again to me, I’m not discouraged,” said the 62-year-old. “For me, the opportunity in global markets is far bigger than locking away the extra 20% cash,” he added.

But, the identical can’t be stated for everybody because the hike together with the removing of ₹7 lakh threshold is most definitely to create liquidity issues for small buyers within the type of massive upfront money outflow . “For small buyers who make investments ₹4-5 lakh, blocking an additional 20% will influence their money circulate,” Srivastava added.

Who gets impacted?

Those who pay advance tax have an advantage. “While depositing the advance tax, taxpayers can reduce the TCS amount debited towards such transactions,” stated Mayank Aggarwal, companion designate, Luthra and Luthra Law Offices India.

However, this profit is essentially restricted to the self-employed as TDS (tax deducted at supply) is deducted from the month-to-month earnings of salaried people and usually, they don’t seem to be required to pay advance tax. High-Net Worth Individuals (HNIs), salaried or not, stand to profit from this.

Another phase that will likely be impacted contains these within the lowest tax slab or don’t have a tax legal responsibility in any respect, similar to college students. “These taxpayers will find yourself paying extra tax upfront than their precise tax legal responsibility. Of course, they will get the TCS refund after submitting their ITR, however that may imply they must lock-in the capital for nearly one yr,” said Viram Shah, co-founder and chief executive officer, Vested Finance.

People with annual income of up to ₹10 lakh constitute half of Vested Finance’s total users, while another 30% fall in the ₹10-25 lakh income group. This category of investors have investible surplus of not more than ₹5-7 lakh. It is noteworthy that nearly 67% of the total users are salaried and about 10% are students.

On Stockal, the average ticket size of remittance is roughly ₹3 lakh and the average portfolio size is ₹5 lakh, indicating that small investors constitute a large chunk on the platform.

It is safe to say that large investors may not be impacted by these proposals at all. Small investors, on the other hand, are likely to be hurt on many accounts—from liquidity concerns to parting away with more tax than their liability.

“I believe the removal of the ₹7 lakh threshold will have a bigger impact than the hike in TCS rate on small investors,” stated Srivastava.

An unintended facet impact of those proposals may very well be that buyers may make investments massive quantities in direction of the top of the monetary yr to cut back the period of locking away their funds. The similar may play out within the present monetary yr as properly. “Investors mustn’t rush to speculate enormous quantities in abroad shares earlier than the top of the present monetary yr simply to save lots of the 20% TCS. Investment selections based mostly on tax-saving and never fundamentals of asset allocation, threat profile and goal-based strategy may be detrimental to the general funding portfolio,” stated Amit Suri, a mutual fund distributor.

What are the options?

Alternatives to investing abroad through the LRS route are mutual funds (MFs) and exchange-traded funds (ETFs). However, it’s been one yr since MFs stopped taking recent subscriptions in schemes that spend money on abroad shares following a Sebi directive. The directive got here after the MF business crossed the approved required restrict of $7 billion for abroad investments.

Overseas ETFs have a separate $1 billion restrict, which remains to be not exhausted. ETFs are a superb low-cost different for abroad funding for these snug with buying and selling in direct shares.

Catch all of the Business News, Market News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint.
Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.

More
Less