Report Wire - Centre defends TN Guv’s determination to ship mercy plea of AG Perarivalan to President

Report Wire

News at Another Perspective

Centre defends TN Guv’s determination to ship mercy plea of AG Perarivalan to President

3 min read
Centre defends TN Guv's decision to send mercy plea of AG Perarivalan to President


NEW DELHI: The Centre on Wednesday defended within the Supreme Court the Tamil Nadu governor’s determination to ship the mercy plea of A G Perarivalan, who has served over 30 years of his life time period within the Rajiv Gandhi assassination case, to the President.

Additional Solicitor General Okay M Nataraj instructed a three-judge bench headed by Justice L Nageswara Rao that solely the President can determine the plea relating to remission, commutation and mercy plea of a person convicted underneath the central legislation.

The bench additionally comprising justices B R Gavai and A S Bopanna questioned the Centre that if that submission is accepted then remission granted by governors until date would turn out to be invalid.

The high court docket additionally stated that if the the governor was not keen to just accept the advice of the state cabinet on the problem of Perarivalan, he ought to have despatched the file again to the cabinet for reconsideration.

The apex court docket heard the matter for 2 hours and reserved its verdict after listening to the submissions from the ASG, senior advocate Rakesh Dwivedi, showing for Tamil Nadu authorities and senior advocate Gopal Shankaranarayan, for the petitioner, on the plea filed by Perarivalan. “Arguments concluded. Judgment reserved. Written submissions, if any, be filed, within two days,” the bench stated.

The apex court docket had earlier stated that the Tamil Nadu governor was sure by the choice of the state cabinet on the discharge of Perarivalan, and disapproved of his motion sending the mercy plea to the President saying it can’t shut eyes to one thing towards the Constitution.

The high court docket had refused to agree with the Centre’s suggestion that the court docket ought to wait until the President decides on the problem. It had instructed the Centre that the governor was sure by the help and recommendation given by the Tamil Nadu Council of Ministers underneath Article 161 of the Constitution whereas directing the Centre to submit its response.

“It is a matter to be decided by the court, the decision of the Governor was not even needed, he is bound by the decision of the council of ministers. We will have to look into this,” the bench had instructed the Additional Solicitor General.

On March 9, the highest court docket had granted bail to Perarivalan whereas paying attention to his lengthy incarceration of over 35 years and no historical past of complaints when out on parole.

It had stated the pleas must be heard lastly due to the stand taken by the Centre that the state authorities doesn’t have the ability to entertain the mercy petition underneath Article 161 (energy of the governor to grant remission) of the Constitution for the reason that convict has already taken the advantage of remission earlier when his demise penalty was commuted to life imprisonment.

The court docket has been listening to pleas together with the one by which Perarivalan sought suspension of his life sentence within the case until the MDMA probe is accomplished.